First-reply checklist for insurance agency and broker client chats
This checklist shows what the first reply to a client message should hold at an insurance agency or brokerage, whether it is a certificate, a change to cover or a loss. It is for agency owners and the AI agent answering for them.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent anywhere or saved.
Before you start
Agency clients write with a deadline attached. A landlord wants proof of cover before keys are handed over. A driver has just been added to the household. A shop owner has a delivery truck with a dented door. Whatever the message, the first reply decides whether the client feels looked after or left to chase.
Tick each point as you read. Each gap is a place where a client may ring three times, ask a colleague, or wonder whether you have forgotten them. Share the finished list with whoever answers your chats, so a first reply sounds the same on a Monday morning as on a Friday evening.
Tick each one as you go. 0 of 10 done.
[ ] Greet the client by name and say which agency this is. [ ] Ask which policy the message is about. [ ] Name the request back to them in plain words. [ ] Ask for the deadline if they have not given one. [ ] List exactly what you need from them to proceed. [ ] Say who in your team will carry it out. [ ] Give an honest time for the next update. [ ] Do not say that anything is bound, added or covered yet. [ ] Ask whether anyone is hurt if a loss is mentioned. [ ] End with one next step for the client.
What a strong first reply looks like
Take a client who writes: can you send proof of insurance to my new landlord? A strong reply might read: Hi Dev, this is {business}. Yes, we can arrange that. Please send the landlord's name and email, and the date you need it by. Our team will send it once we have those.
It answers, asks for the three facts needed, and sets a clear expectation. It does not promise cover, quote a price or guess at a limit. If the request turns out to need advice, the chat goes to a licensed person.
Slips that create extra work
These are the patterns that bring a second and third message from the same client.
- Asking for the policy number in a way the client cannot find it. Say where it appears on their documents.
- Answering a coverage question because it sounds simple.
- Saying "done" before the carrier has confirmed.
- Sending a long explanation of how endorsements work to someone who only wanted a certificate.
FAQ
How fast should an agency reply to a first message?
As fast as you can with a useful answer. Clients with a deadline will message again or call if they hear nothing, so a short reply that names the next step is better than a perfect one hours later.
Can the first reply confirm that cover has been added?
Only if your team has confirmed it with the carrier. Until then the reply should say the request has been received and who will confirm it, and not that cover is already in place.
What if a client sends photos and details before I ask?
Thank them and keep everything in the chat. Say what you have received, list anything still missing, and pass the file to the person handling it so the client does not repeat themselves.
More free tools for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Hand-over rules checklist for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- First-week checklist for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Weekly chat review checklist for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Busy-season checklist for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Customer privacy checklist for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Do and don't guide for your agent: insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Greeting messages for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- After-hours replies for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Booking and order confirmations for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Reminder messages for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Apology and complaint replies for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- "Let me check" replies for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Follow-up messages for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Review request messages for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Price and quote replies for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Delay and stock notices for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Thank-you messages for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Hand-over notes for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Ready answers for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Holiday and closure notices for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Missed enquiries calculator for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- AI agent instructions builder for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Auto-reply message writer for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- FAQ answer sheet for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Reply speed scorecard for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Is your business ready for an AI agent? Quiz for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Message workload planner for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Hours saved calculator for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
- Enquiry-to-customer value estimator for insurance agencies, brokers and adjusters
Read the guide: Answer client messages at insurance agencies and brokerages.