First-reply checklist for insurers, brokers and claims teams
This checklist shows what the first reply to a new policyholder, client or claimant message should contain. It is made for insurers, agencies, brokers and claims firms, and for the AI agent that answers on their behalf.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent anywhere or saved.
Before you start
People rarely write to an insurance business for fun. They write because a certificate is due at the bank today, a renewal letter has confused them, or something has just gone wrong. The first reply sets the tone for everything after it, and a cold or vague answer makes a worried person more worried.
Read each point and tick the ones your replies already cover. Every gap is a place where a client may phone, chase, or quietly move their cover elsewhere. Share the list with your agent and with whoever covers the inbox, so the first reply sounds the same whoever sends it.
Tick each one as you go. 0 of 10 done.
[ ] Greet the person by name and say who you are. [ ] Answer the question they asked before anything else. [ ] Ask whether anyone is hurt or in danger if a loss is mentioned. [ ] Ask for the policy number, or another way to find the policy. [ ] Say plainly what you can do in chat and what needs a licensed person. [ ] Avoid any opinion on whether something is covered. [ ] List the documents or photos that will be needed. [ ] Give an honest time for the next contact. [ ] Use plain words instead of policy jargon. [ ] Close with one clear next step.
What a strong first reply sounds like
Picture a good receptionist at a busy brokerage. She says hello, answers the question, and asks for the one detail she needs. For example: Hi Imani, this is {business}. I can send your motor certificate today. Could you give me the policy number or the car registration?
That reply is short, warm and specific. It does not promise anything it cannot keep, and it makes the next step easy for a person who may be reading on a phone in a car park.
Slips that cost you clients
These mistakes turn up again and again in insurance chats.
- Opening with a block of legal wording.
- Asking for the policy number, the date of birth, the address and a photo all at once.
- Saying "that should be fine" about a claim before anyone has read the policy.
- Leaving the client without a time for the next contact.
FAQ
How quickly should we answer a new policyholder message?
As quickly as you can, and fastest for anything that sounds like a loss. A short reply that says someone is on it is far better than a perfect one sent the next day.
Can the first reply say whether a claim will be paid?
No. Whether a claim is paid depends on the wording and the facts. The first reply should gather details, explain the process, and say a handler will be in touch.
Should the first reply ask for sensitive details?
Ask only for what the next step needs, such as a policy number. Leave health details and bank information for a person, using the route your team has set for them.
More free tools for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Hand-over rules checklist for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- First-week checklist for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Weekly chat review checklist for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Busy-season checklist for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Customer privacy checklist for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Do and don't guide for your agent: insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Greeting messages for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- After-hours replies for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Booking and order confirmations for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Reminder messages for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Apology and complaint replies for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- "Let me check" replies for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Follow-up messages for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Review request messages for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Price and quote replies for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Delay and stock notices for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Thank-you messages for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Hand-over notes for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Ready answers for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Holiday and closure notices for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Missed enquiries calculator for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- AI agent instructions builder for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Auto-reply message writer for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- FAQ answer sheet for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Reply speed scorecard for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Is your business ready for an AI agent? Quiz for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Message workload planner for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Hours saved calculator for insurers, brokers and claims firms
- Enquiry-to-customer value estimator for insurers, brokers and claims firms
Read the guide: Answer policyholder and claimant messages with an AI agent.