First-reply checklist for insurers and brokers
This checklist shows what a good first reply contains when a customer messages an insurer or broker. It is for owners who want every new chat, from a quote to a burst pipe, to start well.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent anywhere or saved.
Before you start
People message an insurer at two very different moments. Some are calm and want a quote or a renewal date. Others are standing in a flooded kitchen or beside a dented car and feel shaken. The first reply has to work for both, and it has to arrive fast, because a worried customer who hears nothing will ring your competitor.
Go through the list below with your own messages in mind. Tick what you already do, and note what is missing. Then check how your first reply reads to someone who has just had a bad day. If an AI agent will send the first reply for you, this list is also the brief you give it.
Tick each one as you go. 0 of 10 done.
[ ] Greet the customer by name and say who you are in the first line. [ ] Ask first whether anyone is hurt or in danger. [ ] Say plainly what you need: policy number, photos, a date. [ ] Tell them what happens next and roughly when. [ ] Never promise that a claim will be paid in the first reply. [ ] Ask one question at a time instead of five. [ ] Point urgent cases, such as water, fire or theft, to the right first step. [ ] Name the person or team who will call, and give a window. [ ] Keep it under five short sentences. [ ] Offer a human straight away if the customer asks for one.
What a good first reply sounds like
Picture Daniel, whose kitchen pipe has burst. He does not want a speech about your service. He wants to know the water is the first thing to deal with, what to send you, and when a person will call. Three short lines do that job better than a long, careful paragraph.
Now picture a customer asking for a van quote. The tone is lighter, but the shape is the same: say hello, say what you need from them, and say what happens next.
- Mistake to avoid: answering a cover question with a yes or no. Say a person will confirm.
- Mistake to avoid: asking for the whole claim story in the first message. Ask for photos and a policy number.
- Mistake to avoid: a reply that sounds like a form letter. Use the customer's name.
FAQ
How fast should the first reply to an insurance message be?
As fast as you can manage, especially for claims. Even a short message that confirms you have it and says when a handler will call is far better than silence for an hour.
Can the first reply say whether something is covered?
No. Cover depends on the policy wording and the facts, so a person should answer. The first reply can say that clearly and promise a time for the answer.
What if the customer sends their whole story at once?
Thank them, repeat back the one or two key facts, and ask only for what is still missing. Then pass the full story to the person handling the file.
More free tools for insurers and brokers
- Hand-over rules checklist for insurers and brokers
- First-week checklist for insurers and brokers
- Weekly chat review checklist for insurers and brokers
- Busy-season checklist for insurers and brokers
- Customer privacy checklist for insurers and brokers
- Do and don't guide for your agent: insurers and brokers
- Greeting messages for insurers and brokers
- After-hours replies for insurers and brokers
- Booking and order confirmations for insurers and brokers
- Reminder messages for insurers and brokers
- Apology and complaint replies for insurers and brokers
- "Let me check" replies for insurers and brokers
- Follow-up messages for insurers and brokers
- Review request messages for insurers and brokers
- Price and quote replies for insurers and brokers
- Delay and stock notices for insurers and brokers
- Thank-you messages for insurers and brokers
- Hand-over notes for insurers and brokers
- Ready answers for insurers and brokers
- Holiday and closure notices for insurers and brokers
- Missed enquiries calculator for insurers and brokers
- AI agent instructions builder for insurers and brokers
- Auto-reply message writer for insurers and brokers
- FAQ answer sheet for insurers and brokers
- Reply speed scorecard for insurers and brokers
- Is your business ready for an AI agent? Quiz for insurers and brokers
- Message workload planner for insurers and brokers
- Hours saved calculator for insurers and brokers
- Enquiry-to-customer value estimator for insurers and brokers
Read the guide: Answer cover and renewal questions with an AI agent.