Reply speed scorecard for insurers and brokers
This scorecard asks an insurer or broker eight yes or no questions about how fast and well customer messages are answered. It shows where claims and quote chats are slipping.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent anywhere or saved.
Before you start
In insurance, speed is not just good manners. A claimant who waits a day for a first reply feels ignored at the very moment they need help. A quote seeker who waits a day has probably asked two other firms. How fast you answer shapes who stays and who leaves.
Answer each question honestly, with yes if it is true on most days. Do not score the best day, score the usual one. Count your yes answers, then read the band that fits. Ask a colleague to take it too; you may be surprised by the difference.
Answer all 8 to see your result. 0 so far.
Making sense of your score
A low score is not a failure. Most small insurers and brokers answer messages in the gaps between calls, and gaps are exactly where messages wait. Naming the gaps is the first step to closing them.
Pick one no answer and fix it this month. Often the easiest wins are a clear after-hours reply and a named person for new chats. Small, steady changes beat a grand plan nobody has time for.
- Retake the scorecard in three months.
- Share the result with your team and ask for ideas.
- Fix the claims questions first, since waiting hurts most there.
FAQ
How fast should an insurer reply to a claim message?
As fast as you can, ideally within an hour in office hours. Even a short message that confirms you have it and says when a handler will call counts as a good reply.
Does the score mean anything for a very small firm?
Yes. Small firms often reply fast but unevenly. The scorecard shows where the gaps are, such as evenings or holidays, so you can fix those without hiring anyone.
Should I include automatic replies in my answers?
Count them only if they give useful information, like the reopening time and an emergency number. An automatic reply that only says thanks does not help a worried customer.
More free tools for insurers and brokers
- First-reply checklist for insurers and brokers
- Hand-over rules checklist for insurers and brokers
- First-week checklist for insurers and brokers
- Weekly chat review checklist for insurers and brokers
- Busy-season checklist for insurers and brokers
- Customer privacy checklist for insurers and brokers
- Do and don't guide for your agent: insurers and brokers
- Greeting messages for insurers and brokers
- After-hours replies for insurers and brokers
- Booking and order confirmations for insurers and brokers
- Reminder messages for insurers and brokers
- Apology and complaint replies for insurers and brokers
- "Let me check" replies for insurers and brokers
- Follow-up messages for insurers and brokers
- Review request messages for insurers and brokers
- Price and quote replies for insurers and brokers
- Delay and stock notices for insurers and brokers
- Thank-you messages for insurers and brokers
- Hand-over notes for insurers and brokers
- Ready answers for insurers and brokers
- Holiday and closure notices for insurers and brokers
- Missed enquiries calculator for insurers and brokers
- AI agent instructions builder for insurers and brokers
- Auto-reply message writer for insurers and brokers
- FAQ answer sheet for insurers and brokers
- Is your business ready for an AI agent? Quiz for insurers and brokers
- Message workload planner for insurers and brokers
- Hours saved calculator for insurers and brokers
- Enquiry-to-customer value estimator for insurers and brokers
Read the guide: Answer cover and renewal questions with an AI agent.