What a good first reply to a candidate contains
This checklist lists what the first reply to a candidate message should contain. It is for recruiters and staffing firms who want applicants to feel heard from the first minute.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent anywhere or saved.
Before you start
A candidate who writes to you is usually writing to three or four other firms too. The first reply decides who they take seriously. A warm, clear answer in the first few minutes can keep a good person in your process, while a vague one sends them to the next recruiter on their list.
Read through the items below and tick the ones your first replies already cover today. Anything left unticked is a gap you can fix once, in your agent's instructions, so every candidate gets the same careful start whether it is Monday morning or Saturday night.
Tick each one as you go. 0 of 9 done.
[ ] Greet the candidate by name and thank them for writing. [ ] Name the role or shift they asked about. [ ] Answer the question they asked in the first line. [ ] Say plainly where their application stands, if you know. [ ] Tell them what happens next and roughly when. [ ] Name the one thing you need from them, if anything. [ ] Say who on your team will pick this up, by first name. [ ] Keep it short enough to read on a phone without scrolling. [ ] Never promise a job, a pay figure or a start date unless it is written down.
Small details that make a first reply feel human
Candidates do not expect long messages. They expect proof that someone read what they wrote. Mention the role they asked about by name, and answer the question they actually asked before you add anything else.
Keep the next step to one thing. If you ask for a CV, a date and a phone number all at once, many people put the message aside and forget it.
- Name the role, not just "the job".
- Answer first, then ask.
- Say who they will hear from next.
FAQ
How fast does a first reply need to be?
Faster is kinder, and a reply within minutes feels very different from one the next day. If nobody is free, a short message saying when a person will answer still helps a lot.
Should the first reply ask for the candidate's CV?
Only if you need it and they have not sent it. Ask for it as the single next step, and say what you will do with it once it arrives.
What if the candidate asks about pay in their first message?
Share the pay range only if it is written down and agreed for that role. If it is not, say a recruiter will confirm it, and let your team handle the number.
More free tools for recruiters and staffing firms
- Hand-over rules checklist for recruiters and staffing firms
- First-week checklist for recruiters and staffing firms
- Weekly chat review checklist for recruiters and staffing firms
- Busy-season checklist for recruiters and staffing firms
- Customer privacy checklist for recruiters and staffing firms
- Do and don't guide for your agent: recruiters and staffing firms
- Greeting messages for recruiters and staffing firms
- After-hours replies for recruiters and staffing firms
- Booking and order confirmations for recruiters and staffing firms
- Reminder messages for recruiters and staffing firms
- Apology and complaint replies for recruiters and staffing firms
- "Let me check" replies for recruiters and staffing firms
- Follow-up messages for recruiters and staffing firms
- Review request messages for recruiters and staffing firms
- Price and quote replies for recruiters and staffing firms
- Delay and stock notices for recruiters and staffing firms
- Thank-you messages for recruiters and staffing firms
- Hand-over notes for recruiters and staffing firms
- Ready answers for recruiters and staffing firms
- Holiday and closure notices for recruiters and staffing firms
- Missed enquiries calculator for recruiters and staffing firms
- AI agent instructions builder for recruiters and staffing firms
- Auto-reply message writer for recruiters and staffing firms
- FAQ answer sheet for recruiters and staffing firms
- Reply speed scorecard for recruiters and staffing firms
- Is your business ready for an AI agent? Quiz for recruiters and staffing firms
- Message workload planner for recruiters and staffing firms
- Hours saved calculator for recruiters and staffing firms
- Enquiry-to-customer value estimator for recruiters and staffing firms
Read the guide: Keep every applicant up to date with an AI agent.