Spaces

How fast and well do you answer candidate messages?

This scorecard asks eight yes or no questions about how your recruiting team answers candidates. It is for recruiters and staffing firms who suspect good people slip away while waiting.

Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent anywhere or saved.

Before you start

Candidates compare firms by how they feel treated, and speed is the first thing they notice. In recruiting, the person who replies first often wins the placement, because a good candidate is usually talking to several firms at once and picks the one that feels responsive.

Answer each question honestly about a normal week, not your best one. Count your yes answers at the end, and the score tells you where you stand and what to try next. Nobody sees your answers but you, so there is no need to be generous.

Do you reply to new candidate messages within one hour in working hours?
Do you reply to candidate messages in the evening or at weekends?
Do you tell every applicant where their application stands without being asked?
Do you confirm interview details in writing the same day they are agreed?
Do you tell candidates promptly when a role has been filled?
Do you have a named person responsible for candidate messages each day?
Do you track how long candidates wait for a reply?
Do you answer shift questions from temp workers before the shift starts?

Answer all 8 to see your result. 0 so far.

What to do with your score

Do not aim for perfect. Pick the one question where your answer is no and the cost is highest, and fix that first. For many firms, it is the weekend and evening gap.

Run the scorecard again in a month. Seeing the number move is a good way to show your team that small changes really do add up.

  • Fix one gap at a time.
  • Ask a candidate how you feel to deal with.
  • Retake it after a month.

FAQ

What is a good reply time for candidates?

Within an hour during working hours feels responsive to most people. Outside hours, a short message saying when a person will reply is a good second best.

Does reply speed really affect placements?

Candidates often talk to several firms, and the one that answers first and clearly tends to feel like the best choice. Speed alone does not win everything, but it helps a lot.

Who should take this scorecard?

Ideally the owner and one recruiter, separately, then compare. Differences between your answers often show where the real gaps are.

More free tools for recruiters and staffing firms

Read the guide: Keep every applicant up to date with an AI agent.